Plain-English guide

What does a forensic engineer do?

A forensic engineer investigates why a structure was damaged or failed, determines the cause and origin of the damage, and documents the finding in a written report that holds up in a claims file, a deposition, or a courtroom.

Last updated
On this page
  1. What is forensic engineering?
  2. What happens during a site study?
  3. What does the report contain?
  4. What is an origin and cause investigation?
  5. When do you need a forensic engineer, and when do you not?
  6. Who hires a forensic engineer?
  7. What does a forensic engineer not do?
  8. How do I check a forensic engineer's license?

What is forensic engineering?

Forensic engineering applies engineering to a question of cause. A structure is damaged, and someone needs to know what caused it, where it began, and how far it extends. Ryan Philmon describes his own work as forensic engineering that determines the cause and origin of damage to structures. The people who ask include insurance companies, attorneys, contractors, and property owners.

What happens during a site study?

Ryan goes to the structure. He inspects the damage, tests where testing helps, and photographs what he finds. A typical site study involves 100 to 300 photographs. He is typically on site within one to two weeks, and he stays in contact with the client until the job is done.

What does the report contain?

The report states the cause and origin of the damage and the extent of it. About 10 to 20 of the photographs go into the report, with the code references that support the finding. Writing it takes at least two to three hours and sometimes six to seven. When a matter reaches deposition or trial, Ryan serves as expert witness.

What is an origin and cause investigation?

It is the work of determining where damage began and what produced it. The method is to document the evidence first and reach a conclusion second, so the finding follows what the structure shows. For fire investigations the standard reference is NFPA 921, Guide for Fire and Explosion Investigations.

When do you need a forensic engineer, and when do you not?

You likely need oneYou likely do not
The cause of damage is disputed between an owner and an insurerThe cause is plain and nobody disputes it
An insurance claim was denied and the reason is in questionThe damage is cosmetic and the structure is not in question
A contractor and an owner disagree about a defectThe problem is a vehicle or machine defect, which belongs with a mechanical engineer

If you are in a dispute and do not yet have an attorney, speak with one first. An attorney can advise you on whether and when an engineering report helps.

Who hires a forensic engineer?

Insurance companies and adjusters hire one to determine the cause of a loss. Attorneys, plaintiff and defense, hire one to document a cause and to testify. Contractors hire one to diagnose a problem before repair work is scoped or defended. Property owners hire one to understand what happened to their own structure. The engineer's job is the same for each: report what the evidence shows.

What does a forensic engineer not do?

A forensic engineer does not advocate for a side or shape a finding to help a claim. Mechanical problems, such as vehicle defects, belong to a forensic mechanical engineer. TRP works on South Carolina properties.

How do I check a forensic engineer's license?

A professional engineer's license is issued by a state board, and the title is regulated state by state. In South Carolina, the Department of Labor, Licensing and Regulation keeps the license register. Ryan Philmon is a professional engineer licensed in South Carolina.

Reference

NFPA 921: Guide for Fire and Explosion Investigations

National Fire Protection Association

Questions

What is the difference between a forensic engineer and an expert witness?

A forensic engineer investigates and reports on the cause of damage. An expert witness testifies about that work at a deposition or trial. Ryan Philmon does both.

Does a forensic engineer work for the person who hires them?

Ryan works for contractors, private individuals, plaintiff and defense attorneys, and insurance companies. The report states what the evidence shows, whichever side asked for it.

How long does it take to get an inspection?

Typically one to two weeks. Scheduling normally runs 7 to 14 days, and emergencies are considered.

Can a forensic engineer say what caused damage before seeing it?

No. The cause comes from the on-site evidence. Ryan does not guess at a cause before the inspection.

Tell Ryan what happened to the structure.

Describe the damage and where it is. Ryan follows up to schedule a site visit, typically within one to two weeks.