Retaining walls

Why did my retaining wall fail?

Retaining wall failures can come from settlement, soil conditions, moisture, and how the wall was built, among other causes. A forensic engineer inspects the wall and documents which cause, or which combination, produced the failure.

Last updated
On this page
  1. What causes a retaining wall to fail?
  2. How does water affect a retaining wall?
  3. Can construction cause a retaining wall failure?
  4. What does a retaining wall investigation involve?
  5. Who asks for a retaining wall investigation?

What causes a retaining wall to fail?

The causes Ryan evaluates include:

  • Settlement. The ground under the wall moves, and the wall moves with it or cracks.
  • Soil. The soil behind or beneath the wall does not behave the way the design assumed.
  • Moisture. Water changes the soil and adds load to the wall.
  • Construction. The wall was built in a way that departs from its design or from good practice.

Failures often involve more than one cause. The report states which ones the evidence supports.

How does water affect a retaining wall?

Water that collects behind a wall adds weight and pressure to the soil the wall holds back. Water can also soften the soil beneath the wall. The engineer looks for the signs of both: how the wall has leaned or cracked, where water has been moving, and how the site drains.

Can construction cause a retaining wall failure?

Yes. Ryan evaluates construction-related causes as part of the same investigation and compares what he finds on site with the wall's design and the applicable code. Chapter 18 of the International Building Code covers retaining walls within its soils and foundations provisions. The report states whether the construction contributed to the failure.

What does a retaining wall investigation involve?

The engineer inspects the wall and the ground around it on site, records measurements, and photographs the evidence. A typical site study involves 100 to 300 photographs, and 10 to 20 go into the report with code references. The written report states the cause, the extent of the damage, and what repair the damage calls for. Ryan is typically on site within one to two weeks.

Who asks for a retaining wall investigation?

Property owners ask when they want to know why a wall failed. Contractors ask for a diagnosis before repair work is scoped or defended. Attorneys ask when a dispute needs a documented cause. Insurance companies and adjusters ask when a loss involves a wall. Ryan reports to the same standard for each.

If you are in a dispute and do not have an attorney, talk to one first. An attorney can advise you on whether an engineering report fits your situation.

Questions

Can you tell whether the wall was built wrong or the soil moved?

That is what the investigation determines. Ryan compares the wall with its design and the code, and examines the soil and moisture conditions. The report states which causes the evidence supports.

How soon can Ryan inspect a failed wall?

Typically within one to two weeks. Scheduling normally runs 7 to 14 days, and emergencies are considered case by case.

Does the report say how to repair the wall?

The report states the cause, the extent of the damage, and what repair the damage calls for, with photographs and code references.

Does TRP work outside South Carolina?

No. Ryan Philmon is a professional engineer licensed in South Carolina, and TRP works on properties across South Carolina.

Tell Ryan what happened to the structure.

Describe the damage and where it is. Ryan follows up to schedule a site visit, typically within one to two weeks.