Roof damage, hail and wind
Is it hail damage or something else?
Hail damage tends toward random spacing and direction, a fractured mat under the shingle surface, and granule loss at the impact point, and it usually shows on more than one slope. Wear, blistering, and installation defects look different up close.
On this page
- What does hail damage on a roof look like?
- What is roof blistering, and how is it different from hail damage?
- What else gets mistaken for hail damage?
- How does a forensic engineer evaluate wind damage to a roof?
- Can roof damage come from how the roof was built?
- Why did my insurance company deny my hail claim?
- What does a forensic roof inspection involve?
- What does the report say, and who is it for?
What does hail damage on a roof look like?
Hail strikes leave marks with a few consistent characteristics. On asphalt shingles, a genuine hit typically shows:
- A tendency toward random spacing and direction. Hail falls at different angles as wind shifts during a storm, and the damage usually shows on more than one slope. Wind-driven hail can concentrate on the windward slopes.
- Granule displacement at the point of impact, often exposing the black asphalt mat underneath.
- A soft give when the mat is pressed at the impact point, because the fibers underneath have fractured and the surface granules are only part of the damage.
- Matching damage on other exposed surfaces at the property: gutters, vents, AC housings, wood trim, and window screens.
None of these on its own settles the question. An engineer reads the whole pattern across the roof and the property together.
What is roof blistering, and how is it different from hail damage?
Blistering is a manufacturing or installation issue. Moisture or trapped gas under the shingle surface pushes up small bubbles, which eventually pop or wear through and expose the mat. From the ground, a blistered patch can look a lot like a hail hit: the same general size, the same exposed dark spot.
Up close the two are usually distinguishable. Blistering tends to cluster in the same section of roof or the same manufacturing run, and the exposed area often shows a raised or cratered edge from the blister itself. A hail impact leaves a sharp, localized fracture. An engineer separates the two by pattern, by location, and by whether the damage lines up with a documented storm event.
What else gets mistaken for hail damage?
A few other causes turn up regularly in roof inspections, and each has its own signature:
- Mechanical or foot-traffic damage. Scuffing from HVAC service visits, satellite installs, or general roof access concentrates near equipment and access points.
- Manufacturing or installation defects. Uneven granule adhesion or shingle lines that miss spec can produce wear that looks premature or patchy, independent of any weather event.
- Ordinary aging and wear. Shingles lose granules gradually over their service life. That wear is usually uniform across sun-exposed slopes.
- Wind damage. Wind lifts and creases shingles along edges and ridgelines, which is a different mechanism from a hail impact.
A forensic engineer works out which of these, alone or in combination, produced the damage on your roof.
How does a forensic engineer evaluate wind damage to a roof?
The engineer inspects the roof for the marks wind leaves: lifted, creased, or missing shingles, usually along edges, ridgelines, and exposed slopes. On wind claims, Ryan also researches reported NOAA storm data for the date of the storm and compares it with what the roof shows. The report states whether the damage is consistent with a wind event at that property on that date, or with another cause.
Can roof damage come from how the roof was built?
Yes. Poor nailing patterns, uneven granule adhesion, and installation that departs from the manufacturer's specification can each cause damage that looks like storm damage. Ryan evaluates construction-related roof damage as part of the same inspection and states in the report whether workmanship or materials contributed.
Why did my insurance company deny my hail claim?
Insurers use their own adjusters and their own criteria, and a denial does not necessarily mean there was no storm damage. It can mean the adjuster attributed the wear to age, prior repairs, or a different cause. An unbiased, experienced third party engineer inspection gives you a second read on the same roof, documented to an engineering standard.
That inspection can also support wear, age, or a non-storm cause as the finding.
If your claim is in dispute and you do not have an attorney, talk to one first. An attorney can advise you on your claim and on whether an engineering report fits your situation. Then send the request.
What does a forensic roof inspection involve?
A roof inspection for a disputed claim generally includes:
- A physical, on-site inspection of the roof surface.
- Documentation of damage patterns across all exposed roof slopes and other struck surfaces: gutters, vents, AC units, trim.
- Photographs and notes tied to specific locations on the roof. A typical site study involves 100 to 300 photographs, and 10 to 20 go into the report.
- A written report explaining the cause of the damage, with the reasoning and evidence behind that conclusion.
Ryan is typically on site within one to two weeks. Scheduling normally runs 7 to 14 days, and emergencies are considered case by case.
What does the report say, and who is it for?
The report states what the on-site evidence shows: whether the damage pattern is consistent with hail, wind, wear, blistering, mechanical damage, or a defect, and the reasoning behind that conclusion. It does not argue a side. Property owners use it to understand what happened to their roof. Public adjusters and attorneys use it as an evidence-based document when a claim is in dispute. An insurance company receives the same finding a property owner would.
Questions
Does an engineer's report guarantee my claim gets approved?
No. The report states what the evidence shows the cause of the damage to be. Sometimes that supports a hail damage finding, and sometimes it points to wear, installation, or another cause. The report reflects the evidence.
How long does a roof inspection and report take?
Ryan is typically on site within one to two weeks. Scheduling normally runs 7 to 14 days, and emergencies are considered. The written report follows the site visit.
Can I get an inspection before I file a claim, or only after a denial?
Either. If your claim is in dispute and you do not have an attorney, talk to one first, because an attorney can advise you on whether and when a report helps. Then send the request.
Is Ryan licensed to work outside South Carolina?
Ryan Philmon is a professional engineer licensed in South Carolina. TRP inspects properties across South Carolina, including Greenville and the Upstate.
What is the difference between hail damage and roof blistering?
Hail damage tends toward a random impact pattern with a fractured mat under the shingle surface. Blistering comes from trapped moisture or gas and tends to cluster by roof section or manufacturing run. An on-site inspection is the reliable way to tell them apart.
What should I have ready before the inspection?
Any roofing or repair records, your insurer's inspection report or denial letter if you have one, and access to the roof and attic if available. None of these is required to book an inspection.
Tell Ryan what happened to the structure.
Describe the damage and where it is. Ryan follows up to schedule a site visit, typically within one to two weeks.
