Defect claims
Is it a construction or manufacturer defect?
A forensic engineer inspects the failure, compares it with the design, the code requirements, and the product specification, and reports whether the cause is workmanship, a defective product, or something else.
What is a construction defect claim?
A construction defect claim says that a structure was built in a way that caused damage or failure: work that departs from the design, the code, or accepted practice. Ryan inspects the damage on site and documents whether the evidence points to the construction.
What is a manufacturer defect claim?
A manufacturer defect claim says that a product failed because of how it was made. The engineer inspects the failed product in place, documents the failure pattern, and reports whether the evidence supports a product defect or another cause such as installation, wear, or weather.
How does an engineer tell a defect from wear or weather?
By pattern, location, and timing. A defect usually shows up in a consistent way across the same product, the same crew's work, or the same part of the structure. Weather damage lines up with a documented event, and wear develops gradually across the exposed areas. Ryan documents each of these and states which one the evidence supports.
Who hires a forensic engineer for a defect dispute?
Attorneys on both sides, contractors, insurance companies, and property owners. Ryan works for each to the same standard. A report can show that a contractor's work was sound just as readily as it can show a defect.
What does the report cover?
A written engineering report with photographs and code references that states the cause of the failure and the extent of the damage. A typical site study involves 100 to 300 photographs, and 10 to 20 go into the report. When a dispute reaches deposition or trial, Ryan serves as expert witness. He is typically on site within one to two weeks.
If you are in a dispute and do not have an attorney, talk to one first. An attorney can advise you on whether an engineering report fits your situation.
Questions
Does Ryan work for the contractor or the owner?
Either, and for the attorneys and insurers on both sides. The report states what the evidence shows, whichever side asked for it.
Can the report clear a contractor of a defect claim?
Yes. If the evidence shows the work was sound and the damage came from another cause, the report says so.
Is a defect the same as wear or weather damage?
No. A defect traces to how something was built or made. Wear and weather have their own patterns. The engineer inspects the damage to tell them apart.
Does TRP work outside South Carolina?
No. Ryan Philmon is a professional engineer licensed in South Carolina, and TRP works on properties across South Carolina.
Tell Ryan what happened to the structure.
Describe the damage and where it is. Ryan follows up to schedule a site visit, typically within one to two weeks.
